Our Bakery offers traditional Lancaster County favorites like Whoopie Pies and Wet-Bottom Shoo-Fly Pies! Daily store-made fruited crumb pies, lemon meringue, coconut cream, and homemade oatmeal and oatmeal pecan pie are just a few of the many offerings that are waiting for you. Looking for a sweet treat? Take home some store-made muffins, brownies, cobblers, cinnamon rolls or sticky buns.
From homemade baked goods and store-made items, to a variety of sweets and custom decorated cakes, you will always find just what you need in our bakery department.

Wedding Cakes

Finish your perfect day with a beautiful wedding cake from Yoder’s Bakery. We have an assortment of sizes, flavors, shapes, & fillings available. Call and make an appointment with Sandy, our wedding cake decorator. Contact us at (717) 354-4748.

Birthday & Themed Cakes

We offer a variety of decorating options from toy figures, edible images, personalized photo cakes to traditional flower & balloon decorations. Also, cupcake cakes that can be decorated like regular cakes in different shapes and sizes and numbers. Our flavors include white, yellow, chocolate, marble, red velvet, and red velvet swirl. Other flavors and fillings available upon request.

Portrait Cakes

Turn any photo into your very own portrait cake. For just seven additional dollars, your customized cake will be the talk of the town.

Cookie Trays

We provide a variety of cookies that are made from scratch and hand-dipped. Flavors range from Grandma Yoder’s chocolate chip cookies to our chocolate caramel chip pretzel cookie. We can make a great party tray for all your special occasions!


To compliment your deli tray, Yoder’s Bakery has a wide selection of deli-style rolls, including Kaiser Rolls, Whole Wheat Kaiser Rolls, Petite Kaiser Rolls, Club Rolls, Whole Wheat Club Rolls, Hamburger Rolls, Hot Dog Rolls, Butter-n-Egg Rolls, Whole Wheat Sandwich Rolls and a variety of mini rolls to accommodate your dinner.

Perfect Portions!

Check out our Perfect Portions Section which is geared for individuals, couples, or very small families. Our Perfect Portions Section offers the same great baked goods, just in smaller sizes!

Check out our Assortment of Ready-To-Bake Cookie Dough and Ready-To-Use Cake Icing!