Bakery

Traditional Lancaster County favorites from Homemade baked goods, store-made items, and a variety of sweets and custom decorated cakes best describes what you will find in the bakery department. For our local and out of town visitors try some of our Lancaster County favorites. Whoopie Pies range from the traditional flavors of chocolate chip, chocolate peanut butter filled, chocolate white filled, red velvet and our own shoo-fly whoopie pie! Plus, our everchanging seasonal flavors. We offer homemade wet-bottom shoo-fly pies to chocolate shoo-fly pies. (No- we don't add flies) Also, available daily storemade fruited crumb pies, lemon meringue, coconut cream, and homemade oatmeal and oatmeal pecan pie. Looking for a sweet treat. Take home some storemade muffins, brownies, cobblers, cinnamon rolls and sticky buns. When available tryour own storemade shoo-fly cake.

A celebration just isn't complete without a moist, delicious cake from Yoder's Bakery. We have cakes for weddings, anniversaries, banquets, birthday parties, office meetings, and other occasions. Our cake decorators will create a cake that's sure to please.

Wedding Cakes

Finish your perfect day with a beautiful wedding cake from Yoder's Bakery. We have an assortment of sizes, flavors, shapes, & fillings available. Call and make an appointment with Sandy, our wedding cake decorator. Contact us at (717) 354-4748.

Birthday & Themed Cakes

We offer a variety of decoring options from toy figures, flat images, personalized photo cakes to traditional flower & balloon decorations. Also, cupcake cakes that can be decorated like normal cakes in different shapes and sizes and numbers. Our flavors include white, yellow, chocolate, marble, red velvet, and red velvet swirl. Other flavors and fillings available upon request.

Portrait Cakes

Turn any photo into your very own portrait cake. For just seven additional dollars, your customized cake will be the talk of the town.

Cookie Trays

We provide a variety of hand dipped made from scratch cookies. Flavors range from Grandma Yoder's chocolate chip cookies to our chocolate caramel chip pretzel cookie. A great party tray for all your special occasions.

Rolls

To compliment your deli tray, Yoder's Bakery has a wide selection of deli-style rolls. Including Kaiser, whole wheat Kaiser, Petite Kaiser, club, wheat club, hamburger, hotdog, butter-n-egg, & wheat sandwich rolls and a variety of mini rolls to acomodate your dinner.

New to Yoder's Bakery this year!

Check out our perfect portions section (smaller portions for individuals) and our assortment decorating cake icings.

Graduation Cakes

Congratulations to your graduate. Yoder's is offering a full line of custom made graduation cakes. Check out a small selection of cakes by clicking below.